Birthdays are synonymous with joy, laughter, and of course, the iconic birthday cake. But, what if you could capture the essence of that delightful confection in a creamy, frozen treat?
Enter birthday cake ice cream – a mix typically made of cake flavored ice cream with birthday cake components like frosting, cake pieces, and sprinkles. You might think of it as a sort of niche ice cream flavor but you’ll often find it ranked in lists of the top flavors of ice cream in America.
Given the popularity of this flavor, we decided to put together the list of birthday cake ice cream brands found below to help readers discover what is out there at grocery stores.
Please consider leaving a comment at the end of this article if you know of a birthday cake ice cream brand that we missed. We will add it to the list assuming the brand is legitimate!
Also, consider leaving your thoughts (good or bad) about any of the ice creams listed below. We have no connection to any of the manufacturers so feel free to speak honestly about them. Just keep the comments clean so that they can be posted here.
Birthday Cake Ice Cream Brands
| Brand | Name | Description | Sizes | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baskin Robbins | Icing on the Cake | Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Yellow Cake Pieces + Rainbow Frosting Flecks + Confetti Frosting Swirls | 14 oz., Scoops | baskinrobbins.com |
| Berkey Creamery at Penn State | Birthday Bash | Yellow Cake Batter Ice Cream + Frosted Cookie Freckles + Blue Frosting Swirl | Half Gallon | creamery.psu.edu |
| Blue Bell | Bride’s Cake | Almond Flavored Ice Cream + Cake Pieces + Amaretto Cream Cheese Icing Swirl | Half Gallon, Scoop | bluebell.com |
| Blue Bunny | Twist Blu’s Birthday Cake | Birthday Cake Twist Soft Frozen Dairy Dessert + Swirls of Purple Frosting Ribbons | Pint | bluebunny.com |
| Blue Bunny | Stuffed Puffs Birthday Cake | Cake Batter Flavored Marshmallow Frozen Dairy Dessert + Marshmallow Swirls + Cake Pieces + Candy Sprinkles | 1.43 Quart | same as above |
| Braum’s | Birthday Cake | Cake Batter Base + Vanilla Cake Chunks + Marshmallow Swirls | 3 Pints | braums.com |
| Cedar Crest | Birthday Cake | Yellow Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Cake Pieces + Multi-Colored Candy Pieces | 3 oz. Cups, 1.5 Quart, 3 Gallon | cedarcresticecream.com |
| Central Dairy | Birthday Cake | TBD | 1.5 Quart | centraldairy.biz |
| Chocolate Shoppe | Birthday Cake | Yellow Cake Ice Cream + Confetti Sprinkles + Blue Buttercream Frosting | Pint | chocolateshoppeicecream.com |
| Dippin’ Dots | Birthday Cake | White & Yellow Cake Batter Ice Cream + Icing Flavored Ice Cream + Cake Bits | Single-Serving, Bulk | dippindots.com |
| Edy’s/Dreyer’s | Birthday Cake | Yellow Cake Flavored Light Ice Cream + Frosting Swirls + Rainbow Sprinkles | 14 oz. | icecream.com/us/en/brands/edys or icecream.com/us/en/brands/dreyers |
| Friendly’s | Celebration Ice Cream Cake | Vanilla Ice Cream + Chocolate Ice Cream + Layer of Chocolate Crunchies + Blue Icing + Whipped Topping + Confetti Candy | 8.5 oz. Cup | friendlys.com |
| Graeter’s | Birthday Cake | Cake Batter Ice Cream + Cake Pieces + Sprinkles | Pint | graeters.com |
| Halo Top | Birthday Cake | Birthday Cake Light Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles | Pint | halotop.com |
| Handel’s | Birthday Cake | Yellow Cake Batter Ice Cream + Blue Icing Ripple + Sprinkles | ||
| Hershey’s Ice Cream | Birthday Cake | Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Blue Frosting Swirls + Confetti Colored Cake Pieces | Pint, Scoops | hersheyicecream.com |
| Jenni’s | Buttercream Birthday Cake | Buttercream Frosting + Golden Cake + Rainbow Sprinkles | Pint | jenis.com |
| Kawartha Dairy (Canadian brand) | Birthday Cake | White Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Rainbow Chocolatey Chips + Blue Marshmallow Ribbon | 11.4L | kawarthadairy.com |
| Kemps | Birthday Cake | Vanilla Frosting Flavored Ice Cream + Cake Pieces + Candy Sprinkles | 6 oz. | kemps.com |
| Little Debbie | Birthday Cake Ice Cream | Sweet White Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Yellow Cake Pieces + Colorful Icing Sprinkles | Pint | hudsonvilleicecream.com |
| Mayfield Creamery | Birthday Cake | Sugar Cookie Flavored Ice Cream + Blue Icing Swirl + Buttercream Freckles | 1.5 Quart | mayfielddairy.com |
| Milk Bar | Birthday Cake | Birthday Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Birthday Crumbs + Frosting | 14 oz. | milkbarstore.com |
| Milk Bar | Chocolate Birthday Cake | Chocolate Birthday Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Chocolate Birthday Cake Crumbs + Chocolate Cake Batter + Frosting | 14 oz. | See above |
| Nature’s | Birthday Cake | Vanilla Ice Cream + Vanilla Pound Cake Chunks + Natural Sprinkles | Pint | naturesorganicicecream.com |
| Nick’s | Birthdäg Cake | Cake Batter Ice Cream with Rainbow Sprinkles | Pint | nicks.com |
| Oberweis | Birthday Cake | Cake Batter Ice Cream + Blue Buttercream Frosting Swirl + Rainbow Sprinkles | Pint | oberweis.com |
| Perry’s | Birthday Bash | Birthday Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Blue Frosting + Confetti Sprinkles | Scoop Shop Flavor | perrysicecream.com |
| Rebel | Birthday Cake | Butter Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Birthday Cake Dough | Pint | rebelcreamery.com |
| South Mountain Creamery | Birthday Cake | Blue Cake Batter Ice Cream + Cake Crunch + Sprinkles | Pint, Half Gallon | southmountaincreamery.com |
| United Dairy Farmers | 75 Candles | Cake Flavored Ice Cream + Oreo Cookies + Confetti Sprinkles | Pint, Scoops | udfinc.com |