Ice cream cookie sandwiches may be one of the most unrated desserts sold in grocery stores. To us, it’s hard to beat the combination of cold, creamy ice cream sandwiched between two chewy cookies.
From classic chocolate chip cookies with vanilla ice cream to more adventurous flavors like brownie cookie salted caramel and S’mores, there are many brands and varieties to choose from.
Below you will find some of the most popular ice cream cookie sandwiches on the market, and little information about what makes each one so delicious. Let’s get into it!
Brands of Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
Blue Bunny
Find It: Where To Buy
Blue Bunny is a popular brand of ice cream that’s been serving up delicious frozen treats for decades. Their latest creation is the Blue Bunny Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches, available in two flavors: the Chips Galore! Sandwich and the Big Bopper Sandwich.
The Chips Galore! Sandwich features vanilla flavored frozen dairy dessert sandwiched between two chocolate chip cookies, edged with mini chocolate chips. The result is a decadent, crunchy, and creamy treat that’s perfect for any occasion.
The Big Bopper Sandwich, on the other hand, features vanilla frozen dairy dessert between two chocolate chip cookies, for a classic combination of flavors.
This ice cream brand is made by Well Enterprises. They are the company behind other popular brands including Halo Top, Blue Ribbon, Bomb Pop, and even Walmart’s Great Value ice cream.
Chipwich
Find It: Where To Buy
Since its creation in 1978, the Chipwich ice cream cookie sandwich has become an iconic classic dessert. It is made with fresh-baked cookies and rich premium ice cream that is hard to resist if your a lover of these two desserts.
Today, Chipwich makes four cookie ice cream sandwich flavors:
One of the original flavors, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, remains a fan favorite. This sandwich is made with creamy vanilla ice cream, fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies, and real chocolate chips, creating the perfect combination of sweet and crunchy.
For those who prefer things minty, the Mint Chocolate Chip flavor is a must try. It features mint ice cream sandwiched between two fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips for an added crunch.
The Birthday Cake flavor is perfect for celebrating any occasion not just birthdays. This sandwich features birthday cake flavored ice cream covered in rainbow sprinkles, sandwiched between two fresh-baked sugar cookies. It’s a festive and fun option that’s sure to satisfy almost any sweet tooth.
Finally, the Cookies & Cream flavor offers a unique twist on the classic combination. It features cookies & cream ice cream sandwiched between brownie cookies, rolled in real chocolate chips for special treat you’ll look forward to eating.
Coolhaus
Find It: Where To Buy
One of the most popular products from Coolhaus is its Classic Vanilla Ice Cream Sammie. This delicious treat is made with chocolate chip cookies and Tahitian vanilla bean ice cream. Each box contains three 2.9oz individually wrapped ice cream sandwiches, making them perfect for sharing with friends and family.
Another fan favorite is the Coffee Ice Cream Sammies. These ice cream sandwiches are made with double chocolate cookies and espresso coffee ice cream. They are perfect for anyone who loves coffee and chocolate.
For those who want to try something different, the OG Vanilla Ice Cream Sammie is a great choice. This ice cream sandwich is made with double chocolate cookies and Tahitian vanilla ice cream. This powerful combination of Tahitian and Madagascar vanilla beans, along with double chocolate chip cookies, is a real treat for your taste buds.
If you’re a fan of salted caramel, you’ll love the Salted Caramel Ice Cream Sammie. This ice cream sandwich is made with salted caramel ice cream and snickerdoodle cookies. The cookies are made with enriched flour, sugar, butter, cage-free eggs, Moisturlok, cinnamon, salt, and baking soda. This treat is perfect for anyone who loves the combination of sweet and salty.
The Birthday Cake Ice Cream Sammie is perfect for anyone celebrating a special occasion. This ice cream sandwich is made with rainbow sprinkle cake cookies and cupcake frosting ice cream. The jimmies on the cookies are dyed with turmeric, making them all-natural. This treat is sure to put a smile on anyone’s face.
For those who prefer dairy-free treats, Coolhaus offers the Dairy-Free Horchata Snack Size Sammies. These ice cream sandwiches are made with horchata rice milk and cinnamon frozen dessert and snickerdoodle cookies. The Dairy-Free Cookie Dough Lyfe Sammies are made with cookie dough batter, cookie dough pieces, and chocolate flake frozen dessert with chocolate chip cookies. Both of these treats are perfect for anyone who loves the taste of ice cream but can’t have dairy.
Last but not least, the That Dough Though Ice Cream Sammie is perfect for anyone who loves cookie dough. This ice cream sandwich is made with chocolate chip cookies and cookie dough batter ice cream with gobs of cookie dough. It’s a classic for a reason, and the real chunks of cookie dough make it a real treat.
Entenmann’s
Website: entenmanns.com
Entenmann’s has taken a sweet new turn with the introduction of a line of ice cream cookie sandwiches, available for the first time in the company’s over 120-year-old history.
Its ice cream cookie sandwiches include the following:
- Brownie Cookie Salted Caramel Ice Cream Sandwiches: These sandwiches are inspired by Entenmann’s line of brownie treats and feature salted caramel ice cream nestled between two brownie cookies.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: These sandwiches feature ice cream encased by two of Entenmann’s Chocolate Chip Cookies.
- Chocolate Chip & Brownie Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: This flavor is a mashup of sorts, with ice cream embraced by a chocolate chip cookie on one side and a brownie cookie on the other.
- Chocolatey Glazed Cookie Donut Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiches: These sandwiches feature chocolate ice cream sandwiched between two halves of a chocolate cookie doughnut, inspired by Entenmann’s Rich Frosted Donuts.
- Chocolatey Glazed Cookie Donut Salted Caramel Ice Cream Sandwiches: These sandwiches feature salted caramel ice cream bookended by two cookie doughnuts and topped with chocolate glaze, also inspired by Entenmann’s Rich Frosted Donuts.
- Glazed Cookie Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches: This flavor features a dollop of ice cream between two halves of a glazed cookie doughnut, based on Entenmann’s Glazed Donuts.
Good Humor
Find It: Where To Buy
Good Humor has been making quality treats since 1920, and the chocolate chip cookie sandwich is one of their most adored offerings.
The sandwich is made with real chocolate chips, and lots of them! The blend of sweet, crunchy cookies and smooth, creamy ice cream is sure to satisfy your cravings.
Each sandwich contains 250 calories and 20g of total sugars, with 18g of added sugars. The sandwich also contains 3g of protein, 1g of dietary fiber, and 40mg of calcium.
GoodPop
Find It: Where To Buy
Goodpop Vanilla Sandwiches are a delicious treat that are both dairy-free and gluten-free. These “Cleaned Up Classics”, as the company calls them, consist of creamy vanilla oatmilk filling sandwiched between two chocolate cookies.
The oatmilk used is gluten-free and the chocolate cookies are made with fair trade cocoa processed with alkali. Goodpop is committed to making dairy-free frozen treats and we anticipate them to release new dairy-free flavors in the future.
Kemps
Find It: Where To Buy
Kemps Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches, or Kempswiches, are a classic treat loved by families throughout the upper Midwest. These treats are crafted with creamy vanilla ice cream that is placed between two chocolate chip cookies and rolled in chocolate chips.
The ice cream is made from milkfat, nonfat milk, corn syrup, and other ingredients, while the cookies are made from sugar, enriched wheat flour, chocolate chips, and more. Each sandwich has 330 calories and is packed with delicious flavor. They are sold in 4-packs.
Klondike
Find It: Where To Buy
Klondike, is a popular American ice cream brand mostly known for their catchy jingle “What Would You Do For a Klondike?” and their square-shaped desserts. Over the years, the brand has expanded their product offerings, with one of their latest creations being the Klondike Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches.
The Cookies & Creme Sandwich contains two dark-chocolatey cookie wafers with more crunchy cookie bits mixed together with their sweet, creamy vanilla frozen dairy dessert. One sandwich has 190 calories.
If you’re a chocolate chip cookie lover, the Mrs. Field’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich may be the one for you. This delectable sandwich features smooth vanilla between two delicious Mrs. Field’s chocolate chip cookies. A sandwich has 210 calories.
M&M’s
Mars Wrigley makes M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches.
The most recent addition to the product line is M&M’S Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches. It’s made with a center of cookies & cream reduced-fat ice cream. The ice cream is sandwiched between two chocolate cookies with M&M’s.
Mars also makes an ice cream cookie sandwich with vanilla ice cream and sugar cookies with M&M’s. There is also a chocolate ice cream with chocolate M&M cookies variety but it may be difficult to find.
Nestlé
Find It: Where To Buy
Each cookie sandwich contains 210 calories, 8 grams of total fat, 3.5 grams of saturated fat, and 19 grams of total sugars (including 16 grams of added sugars). They also provide a small amount of dietary fiber and protein.
The cookies themselves are made with enriched bleached wheat flour, sugar, chocolate chips, and a variety of other ingredients, including eggs, dairy solids, and natural flavors. The sandwich filling is made with a blend of skim milk, cream, coconut oil, and other ingredients, creating a creamy and satisfying center that perfectly complements the chocolate chip cookies.
Nestlé Toll House Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches are available in two sizes: an individual package of one sandwich and a box of seven sandwiches. They’re the perfect treat for any occasion, whether you’re looking for a midday snack, a dessert to share with friends, or a sweet treat after a long day.
Oreo
Find It: Where To Buy
When it comes to cookie brands, there is no brand more popular than Oreo. Oreo products are now found beyond the cookie aisle with their line of ice creams.
Oreo ice cream products are made by the iconic ice cream manufacturer, Dreyer’s, under a licensing agreement. The sandwiches are made with creme-flavored dairy dessert with pieces of Oreos speckled throughout it. Additionally, two giant Oreo cookie wafers make up the exterior of this dairy treat.
Rebel
Find It: Where To Buy
Rebel Creamery has introduced a line of ice cream cookie sandwiches that are low in net carbs and high in flavor. Crafted from high-quality animal fats, these treats are ideal for individuals who adhere to a low-carb, high-fat lifestyle, such as the keto diet.
The Rebel Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches come in four different flavors, including Triple Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Vanilla, Double Chocolate Mint, and Double Peanut Butter. Each sandwich contains less than 6 grams of net carbs.
What makes Rebel Ice Cream unique is that it is made with 0 glycemic fibers and sweeteners, which makes it the lowest glycemic index ice cream on the market. The company also provides the exact decimals of carbs, fibers, and sugar alcohols, so customers can accurately track their intake.
Ruby Jewel
Find It: Where To Buy
Ruby Jewel Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches are premium ice cream novelties that have become increasingly popular among ice cream lovers. The founder of Ruby Jewel, Lisa Herlinger, created these sandwiches to provide a unique and elevated ice cream experience to ice cream cookie sandwich fans.
- The Classic (chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich)
- Lemon Lavender
- Chocolate Mint
- Salted Caramel
- Oatmeal Butterscotch
- Strawberry
- Peanut Butter
- Lemon (Spring Seasonal)
- Campfire S’mores (Summer Seasonal)
Skinny Cow
Website: skinnycow.com
Skinny Cow brand believes in making real, indulgent desserts in perfectly reasonable portions. Their ice cream cookie sandwiches are no exception. With flavors like Completely Crushworthy Cookies ‘n Cream, Vanilla Gone Wild, The Dynamic Duo: Vanilla & Chocolate, and No Sugar Added Vanilla Gone Wild, there’s a flavor for everyone to enjoy. Skinny Cow® is not just about looking good, but also tasting good. With their full-flavored desserts, they satisfy every craving. Don’t compromise on taste or portion size, indulge in Skinny Cow®’s ice cream cookie sandwiches. It’s all good!
Thelma’s
Find It: Where To Buy
Thelma’s ice cream cookie sandwiches are more than just a sweet treat, they are made with love using premium ingredients and Great-Grandma Thelma’s original recipe. With over 17 flavors to choose from, Thelma’s has something for everyone. Here are some of their signature, specialty, seasonal, and mini flavors:
Signature Flavors:
- Snickerdoodle: Vanilla ice cream with snickerdoodle cookies
- Chocolate Chip: Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookies
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip: Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter chocolate chip cookies
- Double Chocolate: Chocolate ice cream with double chocolate chip cookies
- S’mores: Toasted marshmallow ice cream with graham cracker and chocolate cookies
- Mint Double Chocolate: Mint ice cream with double chocolate chip cookies
- Strawberry Sugar Cookie: Strawberry flavored ice cream with sugar cookies
- Monster Cookie: Vanilla flavored ice cream with peanut butter monster cookies
Specialty Flavors:
- Cayenne Chocolate Chip: Vanilla ice cream with cayenne chocolate chip cookies
- Banana Peanut Butter: Banana flavored ice cream with peanut butter cookies
- Caramel Latte: Latte flavored ice cream with caramel cookies
Special Edition Collaboration:
- Checkered Flag: Vanilla ice cream with double chocolate cookies and vanilla icing
Seasonal Flavors:
- Pumpkin Spice: Cinnamon ice cream with pumpkin spice cookies
- Eggnog Snickerdoodle: Eggnog flavored ice cream with snickerdoodle cookies
- Peppermint Double Chocolate: Peppermint flavored ice cream with double chocolate chip cookies
Minis:
- Chocolate Chip: Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookies
Turkey Hill
Website: turkeyhill.com
Turkey Hill Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches are a good option for people looking for a variety of flavors. Here is what they have to offer:
The Choco Mint Chip ice cream sandwich contains mint choco chip ice cream between two double chocolate chip cookies. The sandwich does not contain high fructose corn syrup. It is available in a 4-count box and contains 280 calories per serving.
The Turkey Hill Strawberry Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches are a tasty dessert made of strawberry ice cream sandwiched between two double chocolate chip cookies. The sandwich comes in a 4-count box and contains 270 calories per serving.
They also offer Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches, which are made with vanilla bean ice cream between two double chocolate chip cookies. The sandwich is available in a 4-count box. Each sandwich has 260 calories.
Finally, Turkey Hill Chocolate Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches are a delicious dessert consisting of chocolate ice cream located between two double chocolate chip cookies. They are sold in a 4-count package with each sandwich containing 270 calories.
